Market volatility tied to geopolitics and energy disruptions often pushes investors toward short-term thinking. Yet seasoned value investors tend to respond differently, focusing less on immediate headlines and more on long-term business value. That philosophy was recently highlighted by Oakmark CIO Bill Nygren during an interview with Fox Business discussing how investors should approach uncertain markets.
Nygren framed the discipline of value investing as fundamentally forward looking. As he explained, “What we are trying to do is look out five to seven years in the future and estimate what a company is worth then and buy it at a big discount to that today.”
This approach deliberately separates temporary macro disruptions from the underlying earning power of businesses. Investors often worry that wars, commodity shocks, or political instability will permanently reshape corporate fundamentals.
Nygren argues that many of those fears prove exaggerated when measured against a multi-year horizon. “The events we are talking about, as terrible as the war is, it might affect one year at cash flow a little bit, it doesn’t really alter the seven year business value very much.”
For value investors, the opportunity frequently emerges when markets overreact to near-term uncertainty. Nygren noted that the current market environment has produced an unusual divergence between higher-multiple growth stocks and more traditional value names.
According to him, “More of our portfolio today is classic value than it’s been in a long time because of this divergent market where high pes keep going higher and low pes aren’t really participating.”
Energy companies illustrate the type of situation that can attract value capital. Even as oil prices fluctuate, Nygren emphasized that disciplined analysis focuses on normalized earnings rather than temporary price spikes. “What we like about Conoco, if oil is about $70 a barrel, and it’s higher than that today, but the futures markets have it there in about a year. At that number ConocoPhillips is about nine times earnings and returning almost all that cash flow to shareholders primarily through repurchase.”
The emphasis on capital allocation is equally important. Companies that lack compelling reinvestment opportunities can still generate attractive shareholder returns through buybacks and dividends. As Nygren put it, “If they don’t think they have a competitively advantaged way to reinvest capital, they give it back to the shareholders.”
Interestingly, Nygren also pointed to examples where former growth leaders have begun to resemble traditional value investments. One such case is Salesforce, whose valuation has compressed significantly in recent years.
He noted, “Salesforce looks like value stock today. They’re trying to buy back about 25% of the company.” He added that, “They are selling at low teens pe ratio,” a shift that changes how long-term investors evaluate the company.
For investors navigating turbulent markets, the broader message is straightforward. Short-term events may dominate headlines, but disciplined valuation work still centers on future cash generation and management decisions. By focusing on multi-year business value rather than temporary disruptions, investors may find opportunities precisely when sentiment becomes most pessimistic.
Full interview here:
For all the latest news and podcasts, join our free newsletter here.
Don’t forget to check out our FREE Large Cap 1000 – Stock Screener, here at The Acquirer’s Multiple:
